Books I've Rated 4.25 / 5
-
Life Out of Order
Finished
I loved The Time Traveler’s Wife. I loved it so much that I even watch the much-maligned movie sometimes, just to revisit that world briefly. I understand people’s concerns about the “grooming” aspect of that novel, but I think it’s kind of hard to discuss outside of the context of time travel and what this sequel frequently refers to as “causal loops.” In fact this book directly (if shortly) addresses the uncomfortable nature of that aspect of the first book.
But this isn’t a review of that novel. This is a review of the sequel.
I really liked it! It’s a very, very different book: where the first one was often cozy, this one feels a lot more stressful, with the looming shadow of climate change, COVID, and worldwide rising authoritarianism – it’s much less of an escape than its predecessor. But I think that’s good. If I wanted that story, I’d re-read that story (or, as I said, watch the movie). By my recollection this book does feel a lot more out of order than the previous one: it definitely keeps a kind of linear progression, but because of the way characters jump around through time, it can feel very disorganized and non-linear. The kind of fatalist struggle with causal loops is I think maybe a bit more directly addressed in this one, and the introduction of a more science fiction subject matter, AI, the interstices, and the future as a whole, lent it a very different feel.
I was a little unsatisfied with the third act,
Much like the first book, the ending had kind of happened before the end, so the actual ending felt a bit slower, softer. I didn’t mind it, because, well, it had already happened. But it wasn’t exactly the ending I was hoping to read about.which early portions really seemed to indicate were building to something big, maybe something very sci-fi, but in the end, the meaning was much more personal than I expected. I was hoping that what Alba was setting up in the first act was going to pay off as something more global, maybe more hopeful after a near-future of dread, cruelty, and chaos in the world. But it was mostly a setup to resolve her own life, and the lives of those important to her. -
The Adventures of Amina al-Sirafi
Finished
-
The Tenant
Finished
Solid thriller. The first half was extremely stressful, really driving home the “someone is ruining this character’s life” storyline with very little reprieve and IMO not a _lot_ of hints about why. I had a hunch early that turned out to be correct, but I had abandoned that hunch by the time it all unfolded, which is I think the sign of a good novel of this type.
The “bonus” twist at the very end, to me, served no purpose and didn’t really add anything except to try to hit the reader with “absolutely nothing here was as it seemed,” but it’s fine. -
Long Bright River
Finished
-
A Drop of Corruption An Ana and Din Mystery
Finished
-
The Poisoned King
Finished
I really like these books. They’re undeniably, overwhelmingly sentimental, but for me at least they pull it off so it just feels lovely, not saccharine or preachy. While the stories feel a bit younger, a bit more fairy-tale-ish, the experience of reading them definitely shares something with my experience of reading the Harry Potter series, before JKR took her castle of gold and became a cartoon villain. This series has some not-so-subtle allegories to real-life villains, and a central theme of this one is the corrupting influence of gold. I hope the author sticks with that and doesn’t turn out to be another disappointment. It would be sad, because again, I like this series a lot.
-
What We Can Know
Finished
-
Manufacturing Consent
Finished
I think the central premise of this book is extremely compelling, and it gives a large number of examples to prove its point. I guess I was a little surprised, as well, that the general philosophy is not particularly interested in assigning intent to the press it’s criticizing, and at times (although I think this was less well fleshed-out) explains some ways in which the manufacturing of consent, the “propaganda model”, is almost inevitable simply because of how the information ecosystem is managed by those in power.
It does spend a lot of time on specific events, which is fine but also I think left room for the criticism that there was an axe to grind. Even though it’s been updated and revised, it’s still largely focused on things half a century ago, and while I think the book made few excuses for the actions what could be considered ideological allies on the left (the main argument is generally “here are similar bad things that happened, one under a communist government, and one under that of a generally-right-leaning American ally, and here’s how coverage differed”) it did, at times, read as defense.
And for me, as someone who was born after much of this took place, I didn’t have solid footing for judging how much of the information coming my way had its own ideological slant, so I was forced to take much of it at face value. That worked best in cases where direct quotes were at play—for example juxtaposing a right-wing think tank’s criticism of Vietnam War coverage with the actual things people inside the US Government had been saying at the time, and showing that if anything, press coverage was rosier than the internal narrative.
I think that while the events discussed were from a different era, the most maddening thing in this book is watching how the right is still trying to work the refs in exactly the same way, and actually getting results—see, for example, the recent changes at CBS. It’s been longer than my lifetime that smart people have been pointing out the harm that things like access journalism can do, and the way in which the media is manipulated by the government and especially by right-wing and military interests; and yet we still have pillars of the news world standing firm on the idea that actually, the media has a left-wing bias problem. So much of the debate we’re hearing today was already well-trodden ground when this book was first published almost 40 years ago, and that’s … bleak.
-
I See You
Finished
A well-made thriller. The central element of the thriller, the website, is a kind of fascinating idea that I could totally see someone making in real life (which is not an endorsement—more of a “tech has an ethics problem” thing). The obligatory twists and turns as we find out what was happening were entertaining and not always expected.
The epilogue was a little weird, as it had a major twist that didn’t feel epilogue-worthy; but for what it’s worth, that twist was one of the few I had guessed. -
All That We See or Seem
Finished
I really enjoyed this book, but I liked the first half a lot more than the second. There is a major, and kind of disorienting, pivot at that point and it goes from having a clear arc to a kind of listlessness with the kind of aftermath of the first half of the book.
I was certain Piers and Elli were both alive, in part because of how quickly their death came and went; I was half-right, but the way that was revealed felt like an afterthought instead of what I assumed would bring the book around to a satisfying conclusion. Liu is a very intelligent writer who writes compelling characters and creates an interesting image of the near future. One thing I kept thinking about was how some of the tech he introduced read, to me, as his bets on what current early-stage tech survives and thrives. And it’s not necessarily what I’d have guessed. I think the major suspension of disbelief for me was in the idea of a personal AI that didn’t live in or process via the cloud. We have a lot of leaps before something like what we’re seeing now is available in a form that is both fast and local.
It also seemed rosier about the future of AI—even with the many dystopian angles—than I might have expected.