Books I've Rated 3.75 / 5
-
Wildwood
Finished
This has been on my list forever. I finally bumped it up because of the movie. It’s good! I liked it. I have trouble understanding the scale of Wildwood. They drive around in cars, but you can get from one “country” to another in minutes on foot? And as a parent, the behavior of the kids’ parents regarding their children is insane. Took me out of it. And the noble bandits are regularly robbing farm laborers? Seems less than noble. But it’s a fun children’s fantasy world. I may pick up another in the series at some point and I’ll definitely watch the movie.
-
Age of Death
Finished
Not as much to say about this one as the last one. I liked it, there were some interesting ideas about life after death, and I’m excited to read the next one, but at the same time I didn’t love it like the last one. A solid fantasy novel that I probably won’t think about too much in a year or two.
-
Five
Finished
I think the vignettes that make up the bulk of this story are all interesting – for me, at least, they all seemed to center around parenthood, and they were mostly difficult but compelling stories. The death that glues it all together was much less interesting to me, and the flowery way in which it’s told, with so many “or maybe”s strung together, little bits attempting to enumerate the many possibilities of mundane life, was just … too much.
-
The Republic of Memory
Finished
The world this book introduces is fascinating – the characters, the Safina, the world it left behind – and that’s why I’m rating this as highly as I am because this isn’t a complete novel. This is part one of a story. There is rising action, I suppose, but I don’t know if it’s a personal issue I have or how many others feel the same, but a novel, especially a genre novel, should generally have a beginning, middle, and end – an arc, which resolves at the end. That doesn’t mean it has to resolve everything, but this book had just finished introducing the stakes when it ended. My feeling is that a novel that is a part of a saga still needs to have its own sub-story, and this one didn’t. I realized when I had half an hour left in the audiobook that unless something really surprising happened, the plot I thought I had been following was not going to come to a climax in this book, and I was right. I’ll probably pick up the next, whenever it comes out, because I do want to know more, but it’s the same wanting-to-know-more as if I’d only finished a chapter.
The “new patois” of the novel’s youth felt extremely stilted in the audiobook narrator’s voice – things like “donde are” being enunciated made it feel much less convincing as a new vernacular, and much more contrived, phony. But I’m willing to grant the benefit of the doubt that it reads better in one’s mind.
-
Automatic Noodle
Finished
Fun. I think I had the enjoyment, the experience, reading this that some people had reading Legends & Lattes, which I liked less. Feels less like a novella and more like part of a novel, though. I’d like to read more, and I’d like there to have been a bit more of an arc to this one.
-
Where the Drowned Girls Go
Finished
This is such a good series. This one gets pretty dark though, for what is I think ostensibly a children’s series; I don’t just mean the kind of spooky or gothy themes of some of the other Doors, which are common in this series, but the Whitethorn Institute is cruel and abusive in a very different way. The Institute’s storyline doesn’t resolve though; I’m hoping future books at least move that along? Which I don’t think is a guarantee in the way this series works.
-
Guilty by Definition
Finished
An enjoyable mystery. The puzzles were fun, and felt like I might have figured some of them out if I had been reading instead of listening; but let’s be honest, probably not. Those and the overall linguistic angle added a fun background to a somewhat standard “ghosts of the past” type mystery.
-
Camp Zero
Finished
I really thought I’d like this more than I did. It was interesting, but it seemed to have a “point”… that it never really got to. Like there were undercurrents of a philosophical or ethical statement being made, and plenty of broader ideas were clear—the world is cruel to women; capitalism is a monster; the environment will change—and I generally agree, but it never added up to any more compelling thesis. Also the fixation on overpopulation was strange to read; it feels like a theme from a prior era, and dampened the anti-corporate argument. It all seemed to build toward something and then just kind of end. Which left me with just the impact of the vignettes it pieced together, which were interesting but a little disappointing as a whole.
-
The Spider
Finished
It took me a little while to get into this one. I had forgotten where the last left off, and a decent way into the book it still rang very few bells. But it got going, I got back into the swing of the characters, and I enjoyed the third act. I’m really curious how the trilogy resolves, because while Carew is intent on ensuring “gray-ness” in his characters, Bellamus is hardly a villain, and if Roper’s plans are essentially
, then like… that’s bad, unequivocally. I’ll definitely read the conclusion soon.genocide -
A Stranger in the House A Novel
Finished
I was largely entertained by this book, and it generally kept me guessing, which is most of what I want out of a thriller. A good thriller has enough “a-ha, I thought so” moments without letting you guess the whole thing, and this did well enough on that front, for me. I’m deducting points for the
trope, and for the fact that it got a little cartoonish at points.woman lies about abuse for personal gain -
First Lie Wins
Finished
This one was a lot of fun. I think I went in expecting, I don’t know what to call it, a “domestic thriller?” And maybe it’s a spoiler, though the first “twist” happens quite early—
So I think for a bit I was kind of disoriented, my mind still trying to turn it into a different kind of book. But once I adjusted my frame of view, it was a fun ride. Lots of twists, many of which I didn’t anticipate. I’ll definitely pick up Elston’s next.it’s more of a heist or crime thriller. -
Recursion
Finished
As with most of Crouch’s books that I’ve read: fun, worth reading, nothing particularly mind-blowing. A quick, entertaining experiment with an interesting semi-scientific concept. This felt like the book The Third Rule of Time Travel wanted to be.
I guess I wish the ending hadn’t elided the actual, final resolution of the issue the book is built around trying to solve. And I think skipping to “we had a romance in another timeline” so that now there’s a romance felt kind of cheap; I never really bought into that relationship. -
Bonfire
Finished
A pretty well-constructed thriller. Lots of tropes, and I had a few major points figured out long before they were revealed, but not everything, so when it all came together it was still a satisfying conclusion—satisfying in terms of a thriller’s construction, of course, not in terms of the kind of dark content.
As an aside, the protagonist felt very much like a character who might be played by the author, to me. I don’t think that’s a bad thing at all; just interesting.
-
The Atlas Paradox The Atlas Book 2
Finished
I enjoyed returning to these characters but the plot lacked a strong arc. I think this is often a problem with middle books in a series. I think it also got a little fractured in the last third, and didn’t cleanly handle the way in which the characters appear to be kind of pairing up. It felt like some of their conversations were almost déjà vu—entendu, I guess.
-
Everyone Here Is Lying
Finished