Reading
I read a lot, mostly in the form of audiobooks. I have enough audiobooks that I built an app to manage the files. Here’s what I’m reading, what I’ve read, and what I’m looking to read next.
Read
-
The Toll
Finished
I think this wrapped up the series pretty well. I do feel like, at times, it was almost more of a kind of description of a possible ideal (with a big asterisk) future than a novel, and it almost left the characters behind as it did that. And I’m not actually sure I think the eventual state of affairs
on Earth It was interesting that at a certain point, I started wondering if the book was going to wrap up as an appeal to faith. There was a part of the book that very much felt like it was trying to draw parallels (beyond, obviously, the Tonists more explicitly) between The Thunderhead and some kind of deity—not just within the novels’ universe, which happened a lot, but more as a meta-narrative. In the end I don’t think it went that way.
I do kind of wish we learned more about the world Citra and Rowan ended up building—we learned a bit about the Tonists through the theological interludes (and, disappointingly, learned how much information was clearly lost), but we only got a brief look at Citra waking up at the very end.
-
What We Can Know
Finished
-
The Last Session
Finished
I picked this up after mostly enjoying The Writing Retreat, and so I knew going in that there was a risk that, like that novel, this one would be muddied by a layer of “is it real or isn’t it” supernatural/mystical elements. I didn’t love it either time—mostly because I think it’s just not compelling to not commit. In this book, like the last, everything supernatural could generally be hand-waved away (although there are a lot of “coincidences” in this one that don’t really get explained) as dreams, delusions, hallucinations, etc. But I feel like: do it or don’t. Either commit to the premise and let things actually be supernatural, or commit to the premise that they weren’t. The gray area makes for a much less satisfying thriller, for me, because thrillers are all about “what’s really happening here?” and leaving the answer as “who knows?” is just kind of frustrating. But it was an entertaining-enough read. I didn’t hate it, overall. I just think it could’ve been more satisfying when it was all over.
-
Manufacturing Consent
Finished
I think the central premise of this book is extremely compelling, and it gives a large number of examples to prove its point. I guess I was a little surprised, as well, that the general philosophy is not particularly interested in assigning intent to the press it’s criticizing, and at times (although I think this was less well fleshed-out) explains some ways in which the manufacturing of consent, the “propaganda model”, is almost inevitable simply because of how the information ecosystem is managed by those in power.
It does spend a lot of time on specific events, which is fine but also I think left room for the criticism that there was an axe to grind. Even though it’s been updated and revised, it’s still largely focused on things half a century ago, and while I think the book made few excuses for the actions what could be considered ideological allies on the left (the main argument is generally “here are similar bad things that happened, one under a communist government, and one under that of a generally-right-leaning American ally, and here’s how coverage differed”) it did, at times, read as defense.
And for me, as someone who was born after much of this took place, I didn’t have solid footing for judging how much of the information coming my way had its own ideological slant, so I was forced to take much of it at face value. That worked best in cases where direct quotes were at play—for example juxtaposing a right-wing think tank’s criticism of Vietnam War coverage with the actual things people inside the US Government had been saying at the time, and showing that if anything, press coverage was rosier than the internal narrative.
I think that while the events discussed were from a different era, the most maddening thing in this book is watching how the right is still trying to work the refs in exactly the same way, and actually getting results—see, for example, the recent changes at CBS. It’s been longer than my lifetime that smart people have been pointing out the harm that things like access journalism can do, and the way in which the media is manipulated by the government and especially by right-wing and military interests; and yet we still have pillars of the news world standing firm on the idea that actually, the media has a left-wing bias problem. So much of the debate we’re hearing today was already well-trodden ground when this book was first published almost 40 years ago, and that’s … bleak.
-
The Second Death of Locke
Finished
I really liked this book. The magic is interesting, the characters are sympathetic and compelling, and the romance is sweet and sincere. I think the third act lost me a little bit as action films sometimes do—I start to tune out when the conflicts get larger and less personal—but it never zoomed too far out, and I think it stuck the landing well-enough,
albeit with a bit of a deus ex machina, almost literally, averting any significant stakes. The book also does admirably at injecting a pretty familiar Arthurian fantasy setting with some subversion of the Anglo puritanism you might expect, and I think it did it very naturally, and in a number of ways that allowed characters to simply be rather than needing to provide some narrative purpose in their identity. Though it’s probably worth noting that the central protagonists are by all appearances cis and though the characters are bi, the central romance is straight. Which is of course OK! But it does then leave the trans and nonbinary characters, and queer stories, in the background.
-
Thunderhead
Finished
Adequately entertaining. I don’t tend to red series immediately in sequence but I almost rushed to pick up the next. It’s a bit cartoonish, and I think probably the premise justifies that even if I do think some of the concepts introduced in this series, while fanciful, are fascinating and could probably be explored with a bit more seriousness. I’ll definitely read the next, soon.
-
The Atlas Complex The Atlas Book 3
Finished
I loved the first two books in this series. I had read some other reviews of those books that were critical of Blake’s prose, but it generally felt apt for the story, for the characters. This one, right away, the prose seemed to go immediately up its own ass fast—not just whimsical and flowery, but disjointed and alienating. I pushed through because I wanted to know how this all resolved. The prose settled a little, for a while. But the book never really found its feet before it lost them again. The
result of the experiment And then it all fizzled out.
From the perspective of “I like these characters and want to see them succeed,” there’s a number of obvious disappointments, but characters failing can absolutely be a compelling narrative. Here, though, it all just felt like a whole bunch of …nothing? No happy endings, but plenty of people working against their own interest, with little to no character growth and a completely avoidable tragic outcome on multiple fronts.
I was really disappointed with this book, both as a piece of writing and as the resolution to a series I had really enjoyed.
-
The New Couple in 5B
Finished
This was entertaining enough. The tropes were heavy. The horror-type elements were a bit unexpected, but
didn’t actually amount to much, in retrospect? Are we to understand she’s just got a little of The Gift and it’s not really related? -
2054 A Novel
Finished
I only realized after I completed this that it was a sort-of-sequel to another book in my TBR pile, 2034. I wonder if I would’ve liked it better if I’d read that first, because it’s apparent that some of the characters it fixates on from the past were a part of that one. But it’s just kind of … all over the place. It’s about the Singularity? Except not really.
It tries to weave a political thriller without taking sides in the current political climate, for which I can of course understand the impulse, but what you’re left with is a political thriller with no politics. I think I was supposed to like that
Castro’s party was ousted from power a military coup is not something to aspire to—unless, I guess, you’re a former Navy yourself. Combining a deep understanding of AI, biotech, and the possibility of a coming Singularity, along with their signature geopolitical sophistication, Elliot Ackerman and Admiral James Stavridis have once again written a visionary work.
This is just hilarious. There’s no deep understanding of any of those things in this novel. It’s very surface-level kind-of-sci-fi. And “geopolitical sophistication”? Yeesh.
I’m kind of curious to read the other just because I want to know how it colors my experience of this book, and this one was at least easy enough to get through that it wouldn’t take too much to give the other one a shot.
-
A Curse Carved in Bone
Finished
This was a fun duology. The scope of this one broadened significantly and I think with a lot of books and movies that take a similar route, I find myself checking out—but I enjoyed all the twists and turns, for the most part, and I never lost sight of the characters at the center, which kept me invested.
The epilogue was silly, though: she admirably swore off war… and then immediately un-swore it off in a scene that felt like the last scene of The Incredibles. -
I See You
Finished
A well-made thriller. The central element of the thriller, the website, is a kind of fascinating idea that I could totally see someone making in real life (which is not an endorsement—more of a “tech has an ethics problem” thing). The obligatory twists and turns as we find out what was happening were entertaining and not always expected.
The epilogue was a little weird, as it had a major twist that didn’t feel epilogue-worthy; but for what it’s worth, that twist was one of the few I had guessed. -
Recursion
Finished
As with most of Crouch’s books that I’ve read: fun, worth reading, nothing particularly mind-blowing. A quick, entertaining experiment with an interesting semi-scientific concept. This felt like the book The Third Rule of Time Travel wanted to be.
I guess I wish the ending hadn’t elided the actual, final resolution of the issue the book is built around trying to solve. And I think skipping to “we had a romance in another timeline” so that now there’s a romance felt kind of cheap; I never really bought into that relationship. -
The Hunting Wives
Finished
Of all the thrillers driven by “protagonist makes terrible decisions,” this is one of the worst offenders. I just don’t think enough was done to sell the motivation for this woman to put herself in such terrible situations, consistently. I get the suburban ennui, but it really only achieved lip service and we just dive right into “why, why, why are you doing this?” But ok, plenty of thrillers have bad decision-makers; this one also doesn’t resolve well.
The whole mystery surrounding Margo’s motivations is cast aside when she just … ends up dead. And then the villain does the classic Bond villain monologue to wrap it all up. -
Age of Legend The First Empire. Roman
Finished
Most of these epic fantasy series start to lose me as they get this deep into the series, because the stakes get too broad, and even focusing on the characters, I just lose the sense of who’s who (and, to be fair, I definitely mix up names in this one, which is probably made worse by listening to the audiobook) and so I can’t identify with the stakes, the storylines, etc. But I really enjoyed this one. The stakes are large but the focus of the story still remains on characters that I connect to and root for.
-
The Tenant
Finished
Not terribly written, but the structure, the eventual resolution of the mystery, were all underwhelming. Another mystery where I spent much of the book generally enjoying it yet as it wrapped up it kind of felt like a waste. The clues and red herrings put out there were not well-used and certain Chekhov’s guns never went off; which I suppose is fine, and maybe even good in a literary novel, but in a mystery, when you reflect on your experience, those things just feel cheap and meaningless.